The question of whether Mr. Ed was a horse or a mule has been a long running debate. Mr. Ed was the star of the 1960’s American television series of the same name. The show ran from 1961 until 1966, and starred the talking horse, Mr. Ed. The show was based on the story of a talking horse and the comedic adventures of his owner, Wilbur Post, and his wife, Carol. The show was a huge success, and Mr. Ed has become a beloved icon in American pop culture.
The Debate
The debate about whether Mr. Ed was a horse or a mule has been going on since the show first aired in 1961. The show never answered the question definitively, and instead left it up to viewers to decide. The show’s creator, Arthur Lubin, never revealed the breed of the horse that played Mr. Ed, and the mystery has been an ongoing source of debate.
The Argument For Mr. Ed Being a Horse
The first argument in favor of Mr. Ed being a horse is the fact that his name is “Mr. Ed”. Horses are typically referred to as “Mr.” or “Mrs.” when their name or breed is unknown. Additionally, horses are often referred to as “Ed” or “Edward” as a shortened version of their name. This could be seen as an indication that Mr. Ed is a horse.
The second argument in favor of Mr. Ed being a horse is his size and stature. Horses are typically larger than mules, and Mr. Ed appears to be quite large and muscular. Additionally, he is shown to be strong and capable of carrying a rider, which is something that mules are not usually capable of.
The third argument in favor of Mr. Ed being a horse is his coloring. Mr. Ed is chestnut-colored, with a white blaze and white socks. This is a common coloration for horses, but is not typical of mules.
The Argument For Mr. Ed Being a Mule
The first argument in favor of Mr. Ed being a mule is his behavior. Mules are often known for their stubbornness, and Mr. Ed is often portrayed as being stubborn and independent. Additionally, mules are known to be intelligent and resourceful, which is also a trait that Mr. Ed often displays.
The second argument in favor of Mr. Ed being a mule is his size and stature. Mules are typically smaller than horses, and Mr. Ed appears to be quite small and compact. Additionally, he is shown to be agile and able to maneuver in tight spaces, which is something that horses are not usually capable of.
The third argument in favor of Mr. Ed being a mule is his coloring. Mr. Ed is gray, with a white blaze and white socks. This is a common coloration for mules, but is not typical of horses.
Other Factors to Consider
There are a few other factors to consider when trying to determine if Mr. Ed was a horse or a mule.
The Actor
The actor who played Mr. Ed was a horse named Bamboo Harvester. He was a palomino, which is a type of horse, and was born in 1949. He was trained by his owner, Les Hilton, to do all of the stunts and tricks that Mr. Ed performed on the show.
The Show
The show itself never definitively answered the question of whether Mr. Ed was a horse or a mule. The show’s creators left it up to viewers to decide. This could be seen as an indication that the creators wanted viewers to make up their own minds on the matter, and that they did not want to reveal the breed of the horse that played Mr. Ed.
The Character
The character of Mr. Ed was never definitively identified as a horse or a mule. He was often referred to as “the talking horse”, but was never explicitly identified as either a horse or a mule. This could be seen as an indication that the character was meant to be a mysterious creature, and that the show was leaving it up to viewers to decide for themselves.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the question of whether Mr. Ed was a horse or a mule has been a long running debate. The show’s creators never revealed the breed of the horse that played Mr. Ed, and the mystery has been an ongoing source of debate. There are arguments in favor of both horses and mules, and it is ultimately up to viewers to decide for themselves which one is correct.
FAQs
- Who played Mr. Ed? The actor who played Mr. Ed was a horse named Bamboo Harvester.
- Did the show ever answer the question of whether Mr. Ed was a horse or a mule? No, the show never answered the question definitively, and instead left it up to viewers to decide.
- Is Mr. Ed’s size and stature more indicative of a horse or a mule? Mr. Ed appears to be quite large and muscular, which is more indicative of a horse. Additionally, he is shown to be strong and capable of carrying a rider, which is something that mules are not usually capable of.
- Was Mr. Ed’s coloring more indicative of a horse or a mule? Mr. Ed is chestnut-colored, with a white blaze and white socks. This is a common coloration for horses, but is not typical of mules.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the debate about whether Mr. Ed was a horse or a mule has been going on since the show first aired in 1961. There are arguments in favor of both horses and mules, and it is ultimately up to viewers to decide for themselves which one is correct. The show’s creator, Arthur Lubin, never revealed the breed of the horse that played Mr. Ed, and the mystery has been an ongoing source of debate.